In 1986, renovations began on what was the original, white church, which included bricking the building. This was also the year that the Mass Choir was formed. During this time, it was an all-hands-on deck approach to getting the church completed and prepped for its first service in the newly renovated facility. As the story goes, one member, Mrs. Cora Thomas (who was married to Deacon John Thomas, whose father was also a minister at First Church, the Rev. Joe Thomas) at that time was working at a local department store. The church members worked with her to purchase new drapery for the sanctuary, which was used to cover the brown wooden blinds on the windows. Drapery was also hung in the choir stand to make a backdrop, which gave the impression of a faux window. From the pastor to lay members, many were involved in getting the church readied for its debut in 1988, which is the year the cornerstone was laid, the second one was laid in 1994 on Third Street.